Starogre's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[1.. 2.. 3.. Shuffle!]

hhm

nothing, really...rotoscoped, undetailed, overdone characters with a flashy background...its nothing...

UrbanNinja06 responds:

but at full screen late at night with the lights off it looks really cool :D

[Going Down to Newgrounds]

eh....

this really isn't that much to look at...looks like it took a couple hours to make...

4.04 is unreasonably high for this movie's score, and the animation is not good....the movie matches the song, but i think its the song that got you the high score, not the flash animation itself...

make the graphics better and add more animation to it...make it longer too....

even though it was a music video of denvish's most popular song, i still think you could add more to it or at least have had that small section take part in a larger movie...i just didn't enjoy watching it because the author didn't try....

i know this phrase is old, but....

try harder next time and you'll feel better about it...even though a daily first still makes you feel better, i still think you know this is not a very good 'movie as a whole'....

stoners-lunchbox responds:

Ok, let's start from the top.

4.04 is a score that i didn't pick. It's a broad audience that thought it was good. If you don't like it disagree with them. Not me. As for the animation it took a couple of weeks, not a couple of hours. I tried hard like i do for every flash i make, thank you very much!

Making it longer is a no-no if the song is as long as it can get. I wanted to pay a tribute to the song. That's all.

Take part in a larger movie... If that would've been my initial idea, then perhaps... But my idea was to focus on the song. This submission was NOT for me. You can call it "publicity" if you may. The so called "author" has tried as hard as he always does. If you can't appreciate that then you're not a very good audience member because you can't recognise that in me.

This phrase is indeed quite old... You couldn't be more right...

I try harder every time i make a new cartoon. A daily first makes me feel good about my work (specially considering that it's my first).

What makes me feel better is the fact that "some" people know that i'm actually working hard to give them a good show. Unfortunately it's only "some" people...

Thanks for trying to give me decent feedback, but you tried to put words into my mouth, assuming that you "knew what i was thinking" rather thank just focusing on my film's flaws... Those were all i wanted to hear.

[asdfghj]

plain stupid...

little to no animation...the sound was annoying and locks are stupid when they poop out crappers like this...i don't care if a lock submits the movie...i just care whats in the movie, and its a lame lock that has no animation in it just like most other lock movies that stink...

SafeClock responds:

dont bother reviewing then >:D

[Sonic vs. Shadow 2: T.C.]

great job!

i loved the movie.

i liked the special effects everywhere (especially your logo, that's cool)...

however, it woulda been cooler to use non sprites, but whatever, that's what lowered your style points...

the music and sound effects were all awesome too!

Next time, maybe add a small story to get you some plot points or humor points...i know its a serious movie, so humor doesn't really matter...

i hope you can whip out another! that was a cool experience, way 2 goe!

Short-Factor responds:

Well, if you found all of the easter eggs and the extras menu, you would know that there IS a plot and there ARE humorous parts to the movie. As I wrote in the info:
"This movie is jam s**t with content. Extras, outtakes, etc."

[The Ice Cream Adventure]

amazing....

simply amazing...

dustyh responds:

indeed!

[The Future (5SOP)]

VERY ORIGINAL MOVIE!

Good job twinsen, yet another 3d animated movie from you!

The glassy, reflective textures looked awesome and the 3d purple environment just put it all together. You brought out a good industrial future type of setting. The character animation was good, like the wavy arms. This deserves a higher score for how good your 3d models are. Good work, hope to see more!

Like I said before, the only improvement I see is more action. But that can wait :P ...for now :D

orb responds:

Thanks a lot man. As far as I've planned, BeaverElfEater and I are trying to start a series (starting it is the hardest because we have to make all the models) that will be actionpacked.... Beaver's trying to model an entire city right now (neccessary) but it got suspended because he's in florida and the hurricane renders him without power for 2 weeks.

[KamikakuritsoHellsDestiny]

SWEET

HOLY CRAP THIS MOVIE IS SO AWESOME!

PLEASE MAKE THE NEXT EPISODE NOOOOOOOOW!

xtil responds:

Thanks! Finally someone who can watch it! :)